How to create data definitions

Introduction

Data definitions are the technical specifications for data products, which are the cornerstone of interoperable and trusted data exchange through a Dataspace. To put it simply, data products are a standardized set of data contents that can be used in various different business processes and use cases.

A data product can for example describe the basic information of a company, transaction invoice or bill of lading (BoL) used in the logistics and financial processes in global trade. The data definition specifies what fields the data product contains, their meaning and type as well as limits and restrictions on them.

This guide is mostly focused on the technical aspect of creating the definitions and will try to give some general advice on creating a good and reusable definition. Please however note that for the best results the data definitions should always be created together with business functions or experts in the particular field to ensure the definitions are generic, reusable in various use cases and work for various different organizations.

Setup

Install pre-requisites

You will need to install all the pre-requisites listed below (the names link directly to installation instructions):

• Git 
• Python 3.9 
• pre-commit 

Fork and clone the data definitions repository

Go to the data definition repository on GitHub and create your own fork of the repository and clone it.

Both of these steps are described in detail in the Fork a repo quickstart guide in the GitHub documentation.

Set up pre-commit hooks

Open the repository you cloned in a terminal and run pre-commit install to set up the pre-commit hooks.

If you get any error at this stage, ensure you've properly installed pre-commit and Python.

Create a new branch

Create a new branch for your new definition, for example by running:

git checkout -b adding-my-definition

Creating a new definition

There are two ways of making a new definition:

• Using a python file with the pydantic library.
• Directly creating an OpenAPI spec file.

This guide explains how to create a new definition using a python file, which gets automatically converted into an OpenAPI spec file using the pre-commit hooks. This is fairly simple to do and understand even if you're not too familiar with Python or OpenAPI spec.

Defining the OpenAPI spec file directly can be fairly complex and requires you to either understand the OpenAPI spec format or know some other tool that can generate the file for you. In addition there are some rules on how the OpenAPI spec file should be built to be a valid data definition. If you decide to create the OpenAPI spec file directly, you should check:

• Definitions README, section about adding new definitions.
• Data definitions guidelines 

Decide what data to include in the definition

In this guide we're not giving any detailed information on what data to include in the definition or how to structure the data. However we can give some simple rules of thumb:

• The definition(s) should include the data you want to consume or provide.
• Try to make it generic, so it can be used by others, both others providing data or consuming data. In some cases it might be better to create multiple definitions rather than one that contains a lot of unrelated information that only apply to a particular use-case.
• Try to follow existing standards where possible (ISO etc).
• Use terminology and units that are commonly used in the field of application.
• Try to make sure the definition is consistent with other definitions if possible. For example prefer using same naming, units etc as similar data in other definitions.
• Prefer well structured and machine readable data that does not require any parsing. For example, don't define numeric data as a string with a unit (like "21 km"), rather as a numeric value and make sure to include the unit in the description of the field.

Data we want to define

For this guide, we are going to write a definition for some basic info for countries.

Note that the data here has been picked to make the definition somewhat short and varied, not to be generic and necessary useful for real use cases.

We have decided we want to include this data:

• Country code
• Name of the country
• Capital of the country, including the coordinates of it
• Official languages
• Area (in km^2)

Expressed in JSON, here is example data for Finland:

{
    "code": "FI",
    "name": "Finland",
    "capital": {
        "name": "Helsinki",
        "lat": 60.170833,
        "lon": 24.9375,
    },
    "languages": ["fi", "sv"],
    "area": 338455
}

and for Nauru:

{
    "code": "NR",
    "name": "Nauru",
    "capital": null,
    "languages": ["na", "en"],
    "area": 21
}

(Data source: Wikipedia)

In this simple example we have taken into account that there are countries that have no official capital, like Nauru, but we've ignored that there are countries that have multiple capitals. We could solve this by stating we're only interested in the legislative or administrative capital in these cases or defining the capitals as a list of cities and add properties about their kind.

We want the data to be requested by the country code, like this:

{
    "code": "FI"
}

Where do we create the definition?

Let's have a look at the structure of the definitions repository:

The data definitions are in the subfolder DataProducts, so the definition for draft/Company/BasicInfo is for example in draft/DataProducts/Company/BasicInfo.json. This is the OpenAPI spec file. If we'd create the OpenAPI spec file directly, this is what we'd have to create.

This OpenAPI spec file has been generated from the corresponding python file found in src/draft/Company/BasicInfo.py.

For the basic info about countries, we'll create the definition as a python file. However we will use the `test/ioxio-dataspace-guides` namespace, rather than `draft`, thus we will create our definition in `src/test/ioxio-dataspace-guides/Country/BasicInfo.py`.

Initial setup of the definition file

We'll be a bit lazy and copy most of the content from the BasicInfo for companies.

Let's start by creating this simple initial version of the definition in src/test/ioxio-dataspace-guides/Country/BasicInfo.py:

from converter import CamelCaseModel, DataProductDefinition
from pydantic import Field


class BasicCountryInfoRequest(CamelCaseModel):
    ...


class BasicCountryInfoResponse(CamelCaseModel):
    ...


DEFINITION = DataProductDefinition(
    description="Data Product for basic country info",
    request=BasicCountryInfoRequest,
    response=BasicCountryInfoResponse,
    route_description="Information about the country",
    summary="Basic Country Info",
)

This acts as a great template for any new definition you want to make. Let's go through the details of this a bit.

Lines 1-2 declare some imports. If you're unfamiliar with python, you don't really need to pay attention to these as long as you keep them there.

In the BasicCountryInfoRequest we'll define the input for the data source, and in the BasicCountryInfoResponse we'll define the output of the data source.

In the last section, we define the DEFINITION. The converter expects to find a variable with this name, that is an instance of the DataProductDefinition. In it we define some descriptions and a summary and also specify that the BasicCountryInfoRequest class is the one defining the request (input) and BasicCountryInfoResponse the response (output).

Defining the request

At the simplest, we could define the request just like this:

class BasicCountryInfoRequest(CamelCaseModel):
    code: str

We define that there's one attribute/field, called code that is a string (str). The definition is done using python's type annotations.

However, this doesn't give any extra info about the parameter for anyone and doesn't impose any kind of validation on the length of it etc.

Pydantic has a class called Field, that can be used to define limits, default values etc. It can be used like this:

class BasicCountryInfoRequest(CamelCaseModel):
    code: str = Field(...)

The first argument to Field() is the default value of the field, which defaults to None in python, null in JSON. We don't want that, so we've set it to the special value ... (ellipsis), which tells pydantic that the field is required.

The end result of the two above examples are identical.

Let's now add a title, description and an example and min/max length to ensure it's a two letter code we get. This is done by simply adding some more keyword arguments to the Field(), like this:

class BasicCountryInfoRequest(CamelCaseModel):
    code: str = Field(
        ...,
        title="Code",
        description="ISO 3166-1 alpha-2 code for the country",
        example="FI",
    )

If we'd want, we could even add a regular expressions to check it's an uppercase string.

For more details on these parameters refer to the Field customization section of the documentation for pydantic.

Defining the simple fields of the response

Similarly to how we defined the fields in the request we'll define the simple fields in the response.

The definition for the code we can copy as-is from the request. The name we can define rather similarly; we don't need to set any minimum and maximum lengths for it. The area is also straight forward to define; we just need to specify it as a float.

class BasicCountryInfoResponse(CamelCaseModel):
    code: str = Field(
        ...,
        title="Code",
        description="ISO 3166-1 alpha-2 code for the country",
        example="FI",
        min_length=2,
        max_length=2,
    )
    name: str = Field(
        ...,
        title="Name",
        description="The name of the country",
        example="Finland",
    )
    area: float = Field(
        ...,
        title="Area",
        description="The area of the country in km^2",
        example=338455,
    )

Defining the languages field in the response

We wanted the official languages to be a list of strings. We'll need to import List for the type annotations, like this (at the top of the file):

from typing import List

Then we can define languages field using the type annotation languages: List[str] and again use the Field() to add a title, example etc.:

class BasicCountryInfoResponse(CamelCaseModel):
    ...
    languages: List[str] = Field(
        ...,
        title="Official languages",
        description="ISO 639-1 language codes for the official languages",
        example=["fi", "sv"],
        min_length=2,
        max_length=2,
    )

However, like this there would be no restriction on the length of the strings in the list. We can fix that by using a constrained type, in this case the constr. We need to import it like this (at the top of the file):

from pydantic import constr

Then we replace the str with constr(min_length=2, max_length=2), like this:

class BasicCountryInfoResponse(CamelCaseModel):
    ...
    languages: List[constr(min_length=2, max_length=2)] = Field(
        ...,
        title="Official languages",
        description="ISO 639-1 language codes for the official languages",
        example=["fi", "sv"],
    )

Defining the capital in the response

We wanted the capital to contain a sub object in the JSON response, something like this:

{
    "code": "FI",
    "name": "Finland",
    "capital": {
        "name": "Helsinki",
        "lat": 60.170833,
        "lon": 24.9375,
    },
    "languages": ["fi", "sv"],
    "area": 338455
}

To do this, we'll use Recursive Models in pydantic.

Let's start by defining this sub structure for the capital as a new Capital class. It looks like this, when we've filled in all titles, examples and limits:

class Capital(CamelCaseModel):
    name: str = Field(
        ...,
        title="Name",
        description="The name of the capital of the Country",
        example="Helsinki",
    )
    lat: float = Field(
        ...,
        title="Latitude",
        description="The latitude coordinate of the Capital",
        ge=-90.0,
        le=90.0,
        example=60.170833,
    )
    lon: float = Field(
        ...,
        title="Longitude",
        description="The longitude coordinate of the Capital",
        ge=-180.0,
        le=180.0,
        example=24.9375,
    )

The field definitions should be fairly similar to the earlier examples. We'll need to define this somewhere before our response class (BasicCountryInfoResponse) as we want to reference it inside it.

We add the capital to the BasicCountryInfoResponse, but this time we annotate it as a Capital, rather than a str, float or List, like this (see the last line):

class BasicCountryInfoResponse(CamelCaseModel):
    code: str = Field(...)
    name: str = Field(...)
    area: float = Field(...)
    languages: List[str] = Field(...)
    capital: Capital

However, right now, the capital would be a mandatory field in the response. But we wanted to also support countries that don't have a capital, like Nauru. Thus we need to modify this slightly. We'll need to import Optional from typing, so at the top we'll import both List and Optional from typing, like this:

from typing import List, Optional

Now we can change the type annotation to be Optional[Capital] like this:

class BasicCountryInfoResponse(CamelCaseModel):
    code: str = Field(...)
    name: str = Field(...)
    area: float = Field(...)
    languages: List[str] = Field(...)
    capital: Optional[Capital]

This allows the JSON response to have the capital set to null.

Further we want to add some more information about the capital, so we add a Field. Note that this time, we set the default value to None (python's variant of null) to mark it as optional, so it thus becomes:

class BasicCountryInfoResponse(CamelCaseModel):
    code: str = Field(...)
    name: str = Field(...)
    area: float = Field(...)
    languages: List[str] = Field(...)
    capital: Optional[Capital] = Field(
        None,
        title="Capital",
        description="The capital of the country, legislative if multiple",
    )

The final definition

If you've followed along the guide so far, the Country/BasicInfo.py file should now look like this in it's entirety:

from typing import List, Optional

from converter import CamelCaseModel, DataProductDefinition
from pydantic import Field, constr


class BasicCountryInfoRequest(CamelCaseModel):
    code: str = Field(
        ...,
        title="Code",
        description="ISO 3166-1 alpha-2 code for the country",
        example="FI",
        min_length=2,
        max_length=2,
    )


class Capital(CamelCaseModel):
    name: str = Field(
        ...,
        title="Name",
        description="The name of the capital of the Country",
        example="Helsinki",
    )
    lat: float = Field(
        ...,
        title="Latitude",
        description="The latitude coordinate of the Capital",
        ge=-90.0,
        le=90.0,
        example=60.170833,
    )
    lon: float = Field(
        ...,
        title="Longitude",
        description="The longitude coordinate of the Capital",
        ge=-180.0,
        le=180.0,
        example=24.9375,
    )


class BasicCountryInfoResponse(CamelCaseModel):
    code: str = Field(
        ...,
        title="Code",
        description="ISO 3166-1 alpha-2 code for the country",
        example="FI",
        min_length=2,
        max_length=2,
    )
    name: str = Field(
        ...,
        title="Name",
        description="The name of the country",
        example="Finland",
    )
    area: float = Field(
        ...,
        title="Area",
        description="The area of the country in km^2",
        example=338455,
    )
    languages: List[constr(min_length=2, max_length=2)] = Field(
        ...,
        title="Official languages",
        description="ISO 639-1 language codes for the official languages",
        example=["fi", "sv"],
    )
    capital: Optional[Capital] = Field(
        None,
        title="Capital",
        description="The capital of the country, legislative if multiple",
    )


DEFINITION = DataProductDefinition(
    description="Data Product for basic country info",
    request=BasicCountryInfoRequest,
    response=BasicCountryInfoResponse,
    route_description="Information about the country",
    summary="Basic Country Info",
)

Submitting the new definition

Committing the new definition

We'll need to commit the new definition; the pre-commit hooks will take care of generating the OpenAPI spec from the python file. Let's go back to the command line and ensure we're in the root of the repository we cloned.

Let's add the new definition file to it and run the pre-commit hooks to see that it creates the OpenAPI spec file. Then let's add the OpenAPI spec file and commit it. Note that you might get some changes to the BasicInfo.py file due to the black pre-commit hook reformatting it slightly. In that case, you'll also need to add that file again before you'll be able to commit.

Here are the commands you should need to run:

git add src/test/ioxio-dataspace-guides/Country/BasicInfo.py
pre-commit run
git status
git add DataProducts/test/ioxio-dataspace-guides/Country/BasicInfo.json
git commit -m "Add definition for Country/BasicInfo"

And this is what it will likely look like when you run the commands:

Push your branch to your fork in GitHub

Depending a bit on how you cloned your repository, you should be able to push your branch by running:

git push --set-upstream origin adding-my-definition

In case you need further assistance with pushing the branch, see the GitHub documentation on pushing commits to a remote repository.

Create a pull request

Create a pull request to the data definition repository repository on GitHub from the branch you just created in your own fork of the repository.

See Creating a pull request in the GitHub documentation if you need more assistance with creating the pull request.

The flow should look pretty much like this:

Wait for maintainers to merge it

The next step is to just wait for maintainers to accept and merge the pull request. In some cases the maintainers might also ask for adjustments or reject the pull request. Please follow the updates posted on the pull request.